Why can’t we let kids be kids? (by Elizabeth)
In his new book The Power of Play: How Spontaneous Imaginative Activities Lead to Happier, Healthier Children, author David Elkin, child psychologist and Professor of Child Development at Tufts University, writes “We are seeing too many stressed-out kids cutting themselves, committing suicide, anorexic. All of those are symptoms of stress.” He goes on to blame this phenomenon on the lack of playtime.
In an article titled Playtime Packs It In, published Friday, November 2 in the Seattle P-I, reporter Paul Nyhan found other experts who also believe that overscheduled children suffer from a lack of downtime. Nyhan’s article quotes Dr. Jeffrey Kaiser, a child psychologist at Seattle’s Children’s Hospital and Medical Center: “Kids are feeling overwhelmed. I see a lot of depressed and anxious kids.
The American Academy of Pediatrics feels much the same way, issuing a plea to parents to protect “playtime.” In their Caution! Children at Play!, the AAP recognizes that “kids learn as they play. As they practice making decisions, play with imagination, and take active leadership, they also grow in confidence and resilience.” They also quote Dr. Kenneth Ginsburg of the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia: “Each child deserves enrichment activities, time to deeply connect with family, and free, unscheduled time to master his or her environment. “ Dr. Ginsburg goes on to stress the role of “play in promoting healthy child development and building strong parent-child bonds.”
But what parent doesn’t want to give her child every advantage that she never had? Chinese lessons (after all China may be the next Superpower), math tutoring (for calculating interest on student loans while attending Ivy League schools), multiple sports practices (soccer scholarship, basketball scholarship, football? You choose.)
A friend’s five-year-old daughter currently reads at a third-grade level and is constantly purchased new books to read each day (what happened to browsing the library?). She also takes German (her father insists on speaking only German at the dinner table). Of course there’s also ballet AND soccer (no stereotypes for this little girl). And music lessons. She loves to sing but Mom says she can choose between piano and violin.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with any of these activities, but considering she attends a full-day kindergarten, when does she have time to play or even stare into space?
According to Nyhan’s article, “not everyone agrees that there is a problem.” He mentions that “Business leaders are ‘telling us the young people they are hiring now are not as creative…and don’t have the same social skills’” as previous generations.
Hmm. That makes me think that when these children do have some down time, they spend it in front of a video screen. Ah! A topic for another time.
Nyhan’s article offers these tips from Linda Young, Seattle University staff psychologist:
• Set priorities and protect unscheduled family time each week.
• During family time, let everyone’s imagination have free reign.
• Think back to what you did for fun before technology and hyper-scheduling.
Personally, I believe these strategies are even more important for parents and children with challenges. (More on that tomorrow.)
For more of Linda's tips and the complete article, clickhere.




Comments
I really get upset when I see parents overschedule themselves and their kids with activities. There is something to be said for having a day to play Barbies or Tonka trucks and getting dirty in the mud. Life teaches you more than anything else.
Posted by: Mav | November 6, 2007 7:15 AM
Such an important topic. I just had a conversation with a mom yesterday who was upset by the fact that her son's pre-k teacher "takes them outside to play" so often. "Instead of wasting time outdoors," she told me, "she could be teaching them something." As a former classroom teacher and passionate educator myself, I can't help but applaud the perspective you lend here. I am all for play....and the effect it has on the brain. Glad I found you through NaBloPoMo
Posted by: Angela | November 6, 2007 12:06 PM
What an interesting site. And a great post. You're preaching to the choir with me, but it's nice to have a reminder that the work of kids is play.
Posted by: WhoSheShe | November 6, 2007 1:29 PM
I completely agree but I think parents today are conflicted, certainly here in N America. Just arrived here after spending 5 years in Italy and seeing a completely radical change of lifestyle from European ( which I am) to American I see that people think differently about play. Everyone seems to want to fill empty time with something. Although you need to prepare for the future there needs to be a balance for play related activities that are unscheduled. Kids learn so much in those unscheduled times. Part of the reason I started my site was to give parents alternatives to the marketing pressure to buy more and it makes your kids better. Instead,start playing with them Use stuff around your house. Let them get on with it without you and let their imagination soar.
Posted by: Melitsa | November 7, 2007 6:01 AM